Table 2 The quality framework

1

Minimum quality threshold

1) Does the study report empirical research or is it merely a ’lesson learnt’ report based on expert opinion gathering?

2) The objectives and aims of the study are clearly communicated, including the reasoning for why the study was undertaken?

3) Does the study provide with adequate information regarding the context in which the research was carried out?

5/6

2

Rigor

1) Is the research design appropriate to address the objectives of the research?

2) Is there any data collection method used and is it appropriate?

3/4

3

3.1 Credibility

3.2 Relevance

1) Does the study report findings in a clear and unbiased manner?

2) Does the study provide value for practice or research?

3/4